Young Australians are quietly dismantling one of the most ingrained luxury traditions.
Amid ongoing cost-of-living pressures and shifting social values, Gen Z and Millennial buyers are turning their backs on traditional mined diamonds in record numbers — and a fast-growing category is stepping into the void.
Obsessed with current jewellery trends? Download our new app and never miss a headline
Once accounting for just a fraction of sales, lab-grown diamonds now make up over 45 per cent of all engagement rings sold in Australia — with some industry data indicating global adoption rates are pushing past 60 per cent.
Running parallel to the lab-grown boom is the explosion of ‘demi-fine’ jewellery, a category projected to swell into a $9.1 billion industry globally over the next decade.
It promises an investment look at everyday prices, but despite its rapid rise, industry insiders remain fiercely divided over what this shift means for consumers and the future of luxury.
The 80 per cent Gen Z shift
For budget-conscious shoppers, the main appeal of lab-grown diamonds boils down to simple math: getting an identical stone for a fraction of the cost.
Recent research conducted by retailer Diamonds Factory revealed that 80 per cent of Gen Z Australians would choose or consider a lab-grown diamond if it meant getting a bigger or better ring for the same price.
Across all Australian demographics, nearly three in four Aussies said they would consider making the switch.
Brad Harvey, Jewellery Expert at Diamonds Factory, says the shift reflects a fundamental change in how younger generations view luxury and spending.
“Couples who may previously have needed to compromise on carat size, cut or other specifications can often explore larger stones while staying within the same overall price range,” Mr Harvey explained to news.com.au.
“As a result, we are seeing customers become more open to larger centre stones and more statement-making designs.”
Liam Whittaker, founder & CEO at fine jewellery label HEIREST, agrees that buyer perception has shifted radically over a short period, and that Gen Z is leading the way with this trend.
“The younger shopper is definitely leading that charge, fully understanding these lab-grown diamonds are structurally, chemically and optically identical,” Mr Whittaker told news.com.au.
“In Australia, we’re seeing customers retain those savings and put them towards the wedding or honeymoon.”
A massive education gap
Despite the surge in popularity, significant confusion remains about what lab-grown diamonds and demi-fine pieces actually are.
Diamonds Factory’s research uncovered that many people are still confusing them with cubic zirconias or cheap imitations.
“There’s still an education gap,” Mr Harvey noted.
“We still speak to consumers who assume they’re imitation diamonds or something entirely different … there’s still plenty of education to be done.”
The confusion extends to demi-fine jewellery — typically defined as pieces crafted from sterling silver and finished with a thick layer of gold plating (such as 18k gold over silver). While designed to bridge the gap between green-skin fast fashion and solid gold, veterans in the trade warn consumers to manage their expectations.
Is it really a ‘smart’ investment?
The debate over long-term value exposes a deeper divide between modern direct-to-consumer labels and traditional master jewellers.
As lab-grown production scales globally, wholesale prices have plummeted.
Instead of losing buyers to lab-grown alternatives, Garry Holloway, founder of Holloway Diamonds, says his traditional store is actually seeing a spike in demand for natural diamonds.
“At Holloway Diamonds, we are actually experiencing a desire for larger natural diamonds, possibly because ladies are getting size envy,” he said.
However, younger brands counter that today’s consumers aren’t looking at jewellery as an asset to pawn off later, but rather as an accessible style statement for the present.
“Luxury doesn’t necessarily have to mean spending the most money,” Mr Harvey said.
“Shoppers have more choice and access to more information than ever before, so they’re asking more questions about what they’re buying and what they’re actually paying for.”
The battle for the luxury market
The rapid growth of both demi-fine jewellery and lab-grown diamonds has left legacy fashion houses facing a sticky dilemma.
Traditional luxury brands have built multibillion-dollar empires on natural scarcity, romantic storytelling, and high price tags — making a pivot toward lab-grown or gold-plated collections a risky brand move.
Lauren Sommer, Co-Founder of LAVANA Jewellery, claims her brand uses fine jewels to “open people’s minds to the fact that you can get high-quality pieces that make you look and feel a million bucks”.
Ms Sommer told news.com.au that lab-grown diamonds make “fine jewellery accessible to many more people”.
Overall, lab-grown diamonds have the same longevity as real diamonds, and maintain their quality through wear, and Aussies are opening their eyes to the brilliance of this new sector.
While direct-to-consumer brands continue to capture market share, giant high-street retailers like Pandora and Lovisa are rapidly expanding their footprint in higher-end demi-fine lines.
Whether major legacy houses ever adopt lab-grown diamonds or not, one thing is clear: Australian shoppers are rewriting the rules of engagement ring norms, proving that a sparkle doesn’t need to come with a lifetime of debt.
